Replacing Roof vs Roof Repairs: Pros and Cons

If  you’re having trouble deciding between roofing repairs or a complete roof replacement? 

The decision can feel overwhelming, especially when considering the potential costs. 

But, while roof repairs might seem cheaper than a replacement roof, if this is the wrong option, it can lead to ongoing problems like roof leaks in harsh weather, further damage to internal structures, and increased energy costs. 

In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of both options. This will help you make an informed decision on what to do about your roof and how to choose a reliable roofer. 

At Cambridgeshire Roofing, we’re roofing experts. We understand when roof repairs are appropriate, and when new roof installations are needed. Let us help guide you on making the right decision. 

What’s The Difference Between Replacing a Roof and Repairing a Roof?

The main difference lies in the extent of the work. 

Roof repair involves fixing specific types of roof damage, such as broken tiles, roof leaks, or loose tiles.

Fixing a few loose roof tiles is very different to total roof removal and replacement. 

Roof replacement means removing and replacing the entire roof. 

While the average cost of a roof replacement varies based on size, the type of roof, and your choice of materials, Cambridgeshire Roofing offers roof installations starting at £6000. 

Roof repairs are usually quicker and can feel cost-effective at the time. But they may not always solve long-term problems, especially if the roof structure is compromised. This can lead to additional costs later.

If you’re smart enough to keep on top of regular maintenance and only need minor repairs, like slight damage to roof tiles, this can be a great choice. But if you’re looking at more substantial repairs, you might want to consider a new roof. Let’s explore the pros and cons.

Pros of Replacing a Roof Instead of Repairing It

With the right professional company working on your roof, it’s a sound investment. A new roof built from durable materials can offer you a long-lasting and low maintenance solution to your current roofing issues.

Let’s dive into why and how.

1. You’ll Get It Back in House Value

A complete roof replacement can boost your home’s resale value, which is a key selling point for potential buyers. According to a survey by Zopa, when you add a new roof, on average, you’ll see a 63% return on investment when selling your home.

So, if you pay £10,000 for a new roof, you’ll add £6,300 to the property’s resale value.

An attractive, quality roofing solution increases your home’s market appeal as new buyers won’t have to worry about roofing issues in the near future. This can potentially lead to a higher selling price. 

With this in mind, when choosing between replacement and repairs, consider whether the repairs cost more than 50% of a new roof. If so, they’re actually more expensive if you’re planning to sell any time soon.

Investing in a new roof with Cambridgeshire Roofing means you can recoup a good chunk of your investment and you can rest assured your home is safe and sound.

2. You’re Future-Proofing Your Home

A new roof provides solid protection against bad weather, leaks, and structural damage. 

A newly installed roof by Cambridgeshire Roofing can withstand extreme weather conditions, no matter the type of roof tile. This prevents further issues like water leaks and mould growth. This investment saves money in the long run by avoiding costly repairs.

3. Reduced Energy Costs

A new roof can significantly improve energy efficiency by better insulating your home, which results in lower energy bills. 

It’s not just that a new roof will cover any holes leading to energy inefficiency. It’s also that the type of material used in new roofs is much more energy efficient. 

While Cambridgeshire Roofing offers various roofing materials, such as slate roofs, clay tile, and concrete roofing tiles, all our pitched and flat roofing systems help maintain a consistent indoor temperature. 

With a well-insulated roof, you’ll spend less on heating and cooling, making this an eco-friendly and cost-saving option.

4. Less Chance of Negotiation Pitfalls at Sale Time

A roof in poor condition or a leaky roof can be a deal-breaker for buyers. Buyers don’t want the extra costs of ‌replacing roof tiles or getting a new roof when they’ve just paid for a new house.

Replacing your roof now can help you avoid last-minute negotiations or demands for price reductions. 

A new roof from a reputable roofing company like Cambridgeshire Roofing makes your property more appealing and can help you sell faster and at a higher price.

5. Longer Lifespan Than Repairs

A newly installed roof has a longer life span than one with repeated minor repairs. 

A well-installed roof can last for decades, saving you time and money on repeated roof maintenance.

Cambridge Roofing Services ensures that your new roof is built to last, providing long-term protection for your home. 

6. Less Maintenance with Modern Roofing

Modern roofing materials often require less maintenance than older roofing materials.

The types of materials Cambridgeshire Roofing use are durable and weather-resistant, minimising the need for frequent repairs. 

A low-maintenance roof simplifies homeownership and reduces long-term costs.

7. 10-Year CORC Insurance-Backed Guarantee

When you choose Cambridgeshire Roofing, your new roof comes with a 10-year warranty backed by the Confederation of Roofing Contractors (CORC), the most reputable roofing association. 

This insurance-backed guarantee provides peace of mind and protection against unexpected costs. While you can trust that the quality of materials and workmanship will meet the highest standards, it’s always good to have a guarantee. 

8. We Have a Wide Range of Options to Suit Your Style

With Cambridgeshire Roofing, you get to choose from a wide range of roofing materials, including concrete tiles, natural slates, flat roof materials, and more. 

Whether you prefer a tiled roof or flat roofing, our roofing specialists help you find the best option that suits your home or commercial building’s style.

Still unsure whether your need a replacement or repairs. Keep reading or head straight to our online booking form below to schedule a callback with our expert team at a time that suits you.Roof